On May 21, 1952, the Texas Supreme Court made a pivotal decision in the ongoing battle between supporters of Senator Robert Taft and General Dwight D. Eisenhower over Republican convention delegates. The court refused to grant the Eisenhower faction’s plea to block the certification of delegate lists submitted by pro-Taft “rump” conventions in six major Texas counties. This action allowed both sets of delegates to be officially mailed to the Republican Party, with the matter to be decided by the state committee, which was largely controlled by Taft backers.
The Eisenhower camp had hoped the courts would declare that only the delegates from the official county conventions could be forwarded and seated, but faced claims that the issue was an internal party matter beyond the court’s jurisdiction. In a divided opinion, the court ruled that it had no original jurisdiction to issue an injunction against the Secretary of State, and that party contests should first be decided by the appropriate party executive committee rather than by government officials. Secretary of State Jack Ross subsequently forwarded both competing sets of delegate lists to the Republican State Committee, leaving Eisenhower supporters with little hope for success through official channels.
This dramatic legal showdown stemmed from disputes in Travis, Nueces, Dallas, Tarrant, Harris, and Galveston Counties, where Taft supporters held separate “bolting” conventions after disagreements with Eisenhower backers. The court’s decision upheld the traditional view that political parties largely controlled their internal affairs, though a vigorous dissent argued the court did have jurisdiction to intervene in this case. This ruling not only shaped the 1952 Texas Republican convention but also established important precedent for future party disputes in the state’s electoral process. #TexasHistory #Eisenhower #Taft #1952Election #TexasSupremeCourt
More Info: